Skip to main content
The Actuary: The magazine of the Institute and Faculty of Actuaries - return to the homepage Logo of The Actuary website
  • Search
  • Visit The Actuary Magazine on Facebook
  • Visit The Actuary Magazine on LinkedIn
  • Visit @TheActuaryMag on Twitter
Visit the website of the Institute and Faculty of Actuaries Logo of the Institute and Faculty of Actuaries

Main navigation

  • News
  • Features
    • General Features
    • Interviews
    • Students
    • Opinion
  • Topics
  • Knowledge
    • Business Skills
    • Careers
    • Events
    • Predictions by The Actuary
    • Whitepapers
    • Moody's - Climate Risk Insurers series
    • Webinars
    • Podcasts
  • Jobs
  • IFoA
    • CEO Comment
    • IFoA News
    • People & Social News
    • President Comment
  • Archive
Quick links:
  • Home
  • The Actuary Issues
  • April 2012
04

Struggling schemes 'will get breathing space to fill deficits'

Open-access content Friday 27th April 2012 — updated 5.13pm, Wednesday 29th April 2020

Most defined benefit schemes should be able to meet their pension promises to members with little or no change to their present deficit recovery plans, but ‘struggling’ schemes will be given ‘breathing space’ to fill deficits, the Pensions Regulator said today.

2

In its first annual funding statement, the regulator set out how pension scheme funding valuations should be approached in the current economic climate. The advice is aimed at trustee and employers of defined benefit pension schemes undertaking valuations which are effective between September 2011 and September 2012 - this is about a third of the UK's DB schemes, with around four million members.

The regulator said there was 'significant flexibility' in the funding framework to enable schemes and employers to meet their long-term liabilities including - where necessary - filling deficits over longer periods and taking account of improved market conditions post-valuation.

Employers should, as a starting point, maintain current deficit recovery contributions in real terms, it said. They will also have demonstrate whether any alternative use of cash that could otherwise be used to increase their contributions to a scheme will strengthen their ability to support the scheme - the 'employer covenant'.

Trustees and employers following this guidance are more likely to reach funding agreements acceptable to the regulator, it said.

Bill Galvin, the regulator's chief executive, said: 'Pension schemes are long-term undertakings. A resilient economy and a healthy sponsoring employer provide the best environment for delivering pension promises.

'The economic climate continues to be challenging, but the majority of schemes and sponsoring employers should be able to meet their promises to members without major adjustments to their current plans. Trustees must produce credible recovery plans in light of all the risks, including employer insolvency.

He added: 'Employers that are struggling have greater breathing space to fill deficits over a longer period. However, we will draw a distinction between this group and those cases where schemes are substantially underfunded and employers are able to afford higher contributions. In such cases we will expect pension trustees to be taking steps to put their scheme on a more stable footing.'

The regulator acknowledged calls for it to allow schemes to make allowances for low gilt yields and the effects of quantitative easing in the assumptions they use, which would reduce their funding targets.

But this would not be a prudent approach it said, because it aims to 'second guess' future market conditions. The regulator noted, however, that it would consider additional flexibility in recovery plans if employers were genuinely struggling to support their scheme.

Mr Galvin added: 'There are a number of economic factors impacting gilt yields, such as QE and demands for UK sovereign debt from the international banking sector.

'We have been in a low interest climate for some time. Yields have fallen further in the last nine months, and it is unclear when and to what extent there will be a market correction. The net effect across defined benefit schemes is not uniform and will vary greatly depending upon the extent to which their risk-management, investment and contribution strategies have insulated them from the effects.'

However, the statement was criticised by the CBI which said it had failed to address the impact that QE has on pensions.

Neil Carberry, director of employment and skills policy for the business group, said: 'Although QE has been necessary to support the economy, one side effect has been to make pension scheme deficits look artificially big by lowering gilt yields at the very moment when firms are also doing their three-yearly valuation.

'While the Pensions Regulator acknowledges this side effect of QE in its first annual statement, its advice to trustees fails to deal with the problem - how "technical provisions", the amount required to cover a scheme's liabilities, are calculated. We need to take more account of the effects of QE when making the calculation.'

He added: 'To help the private sector provide both the growth we need and the pensions firms have promised to employees, the current method of valuing a pension fund must change. It cannot be right that pension schemes with very long-term liabilities, which make them less vulnerable to short-term market fluctuations, have to fund against spot valuations. Greater smoothing is required using data over many months rather on a single day.'

John Ball, head of UK pensions at Towers Watson, said it was 'unsurprising' the regulator had not demanded a general hike in contributions when cash becomes available to companies, but said that despite this, maintaining current contributions in 'real terms', might still be too much for some firms.

'Trustees have always recognised that contribution increases financed by cancelling dividends or investing less in the business have the potential to do more harm than good if this undermines the company's ability to compete and to raise capital in future,' he said.

'The regulator's acknowledgement that paying as much as possible into the pension scheme is not always the best thing for benefit security will help trustees continue to take a pragmatic approach where alternative uses for the money can be good for the sponsor's covenant.'

But he said there were 'the usual ifs and buts' - in particular in relation to the regulator stating that most schemes can afford 'appropriate' dividend payments, but these should reconsidered when there is a 'substantial' risk benefits won't be paid in full.  'Perhaps inevitably when it is trying to police a scheme-specific funding framework, it does not say anything useful about what must happen for these lines to be crossed.'

He added: 'The regulator would be the first to say that its flexible approach to cash contributions is not mirrored in how it thinks liabilities should be measured.  Its message is that companies should just record a big deficit and, if really necessary, take longer to pay it off.

'In general, it is good that the regulator has encouraged trustees to think about the risks to their funding plan, how they might react if things do not turn out as planned and whether contingency mechanisms can be built in.  However, it will be interesting to see how the regulator applies its comment that level of detail in contingency plans should be proportionate to the risk being taken, as so many different things could conceivably blow a recovery plan off course before the whole thing is reviewed again in three years' time.'

Mercer said the statement was helpful in providing further clarity about the regulator's expectations when valuations are carried out. Dr Deborah Cooper said: 'The statement implies that TPR might permit the elastic to be stretched a little further than before on condition that trustees consider what contingency mechanisms they may need to have in place if the elastic snaps. Current market conditions are accepted to be unusual, but may persist for some time yet.'

The consultancy said advisers should tell trustees to take an integrated approach to valuations by considering investment and employer risk together and by fathering evidence for any decisions taken.

'Many tools are available for measuring risk, market impact and covenant strength, but none of these tools is clairvoyant,' said Dr Cooper. 'Although there is regulatory focus on the valuation process, a successful outcome requires judgement and regular monitoring of investment, liability and covenant risk.'
She added: 'Trustees need to work with employers to enable outcomes that achieve an appropriate balance of interests between shareholders and scheme members. The Regulator needs to respect this balance also, in carrying out its role.'

Association of Consulting Actuaries' chairman Stuart Southall said: 'The ACA welcomes the confirmations of what the regulated can expect from the Regulator, although the undertakings stop short of promising consistency of approach or completion of reviews within commercially sensitive timescales. 

'The flip side of the acknowledgement that the use of cash in a business (including for dividends) might improve the employer's covenant is surely that an 'unresolved' pension funding situation might damage the covenant, particularly for high profile quoted businesses.

He added: 'Reducing and ideally removing delay or uncertainty in resolving funding situations is just as important and this is an area the Regulator needs to address.'

This article appeared in our April 2012 issue of The Actuary .
Click here to view this issue

You may also be interested in...

2

FSA tightens up rules for pension TVAs

The Financial Services Authority has published new rules and guidance which aim to reduce the number of transfers from defined benefit pension schemes to personal pensions.
Friday 27th April 2012
Open-access content
2

Pensions funding statement: reaction and responses

The publication of the Pensions Regulator’s first annual funding statement has already elicited a considerable response from actuaries and others involved in the pensions industry.
Friday 27th April 2012
Open-access content
2

Banks must take action on risk management, says Sants

More progress still needs to be made on delivery effective corporate governance and risk management in the banking sector, the chief executive of the Financial Services Authority, Hector Sants, said today.
Tuesday 24th April 2012
Open-access content
ta filler

Pension regulations put under Red Tape spotlight

The government is asking the pensions industry for its views on which regulations affecting the sector should be abolished.
Friday 20th April 2012
Open-access content
2

FRC launches raft of code and standards consultations

The Financial Reporting Council has launched consultations on ‘deliberately limited’ changes to some of its codes and standards.
Friday 20th April 2012
Open-access content
2

CEO's comment: Clear, focused and fit for purpose

Derek Cribb looks at inspiring public confidence through regulation
Wednesday 4th April 2012
Open-access content

Latest from Regulation Standards

tfd

A matter of adjustment

Private assets will continue to shine even under the Treasury’s proposed changes to the Solvency II matching adjustment, says Ziling Jiang
Wednesday 2nd November 2022
Open-access content
ykf

A home run: reducing inequality through impact investing?

Sophie van Oosterom, Wojciech Herchel and Mark Callender consider how ‘impact investing’ in social housing could help to reduce inequality
Wednesday 5th October 2022
Open-access content
hgv

Exchange of ideas: IFRS 17 implementation in the Caribbean

Servaas Houben considers how IFRS 17 principles could benefit insurers in the Caribbean – and what European insurers could learn from the region when it comes to implementing the standard
Wednesday 31st August 2022
Open-access content

Latest from April 2012

ta

ERM reviews needed to address innovation risks, says WEF

Banks and insurers should review and adapt their enterprise risk management to address the risk and uncertainties introduced by financial innovation, the World Economic Forum said yesterday.
Friday 27th April 2012
Open-access content
2

European regulation must strike balance, says FSA chair

Financial regulation in Europe must strike a balance between more integration in some areas and strong national powers in others, the chairman of the Financial Services Authority, Lord Adair Turner, said today.
Friday 27th April 2012
Open-access content
2

Hacking threat on the increase, says PwC

One in seven large UK organisations was hacked last year and the annual cost to companies of security breaches now runs to billions of pounds, PricewaterhouseCoopers said this week.
Thursday 26th April 2012
Open-access content

Latest from formbuilder_item_removed

2

Implementing IFRS 17 Discount Curves: Theoretical and Practical Challenges

The International Financial Reporting Standard (IFRS) 17 requires liability cash flows to be discounted at rates that reflect the characteristics of the cash flows, including their liquidity
Tuesday 3rd September 2019
Open-access content
2

Profit Emergence Under IFRS 9 and IFRS 17: The impact of choice of liability discount rate

With the IFRS 17 accounting standard, insurers need to understand the patterns of profit emergence that arise under the standard, and how current business and methodology decisions affect such patterns.
Wednesday 10th July 2019
Open-access content
2

Whitepaper: Aggregation and diversification of the IFRS 17 Risk Adjustment

This paper forms part of a series of high-level papers designed to provide an introduction to different features of the risk adjustment that should be considered in advance of implementation.
Tuesday 29th January 2019
Open-access content

Latest from 04

ta

ERM reviews needed to address innovation risks, says WEF

Banks and insurers should review and adapt their enterprise risk management to address the risk and uncertainties introduced by financial innovation, the World Economic Forum said yesterday.
Friday 27th April 2012
Open-access content
2

European regulation must strike balance, says FSA chair

Financial regulation in Europe must strike a balance between more integration in some areas and strong national powers in others, the chairman of the Financial Services Authority, Lord Adair Turner, said today.
Friday 27th April 2012
Open-access content
2

Hacking threat on the increase, says PwC

One in seven large UK organisations was hacked last year and the annual cost to companies of security breaches now runs to billions of pounds, PricewaterhouseCoopers said this week.
Thursday 26th April 2012
Open-access content
Share
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Linked in
  • Mail
  • Print

Latest Jobs

Senior Pricing Associate

Scotland / England, London
Up to £60000 per annum
Reference
149081

Outside IR35 - Reserving Contract - 6-8 months

London (Central)
Daily rate contract - outside IR35
Reference
149079

Actuarial Analyst - Longevity Reinsurance

England, London
Up to £55000 per annum
Reference
149080
See all jobs »
 
 
 
 

Sign up to our newsletter

News, jobs and updates

Sign up

Subscribe to The Actuary

Receive the print edition straight to your door

Subscribe
Spread-iPad-slantB-june.png

Topics

  • Data Science
  • Investment
  • Risk & ERM
  • Pensions
  • Environment
  • Soft skills
  • General Insurance
  • Regulation Standards
  • Health care
  • Technology
  • Reinsurance
  • Global
  • Life insurance
​
FOLLOW US
The Actuary on LinkedIn
@TheActuaryMag on Twitter
Facebook: The Actuary Magazine
CONTACT US
The Actuary
Tel: (+44) 020 7880 6200
​

IFoA

About IFoA
Become an actuary
IFoA Events
About membership

Information

Privacy Policy
Terms & Conditions
Cookie Policy
Think Green

Get in touch

Contact us
Advertise with us
Subscribe to The Actuary Magazine
Contribute

The Actuary Jobs

Actuarial job search
Pensions jobs
General insurance jobs
Solvency II jobs

© 2023 The Actuary. The Actuary is published on behalf of the Institute and Faculty of Actuaries by Redactive Publishing Limited. All rights reserved. Reproduction of any part is not allowed without written permission.

Redactive Media Group Ltd, 71-75 Shelton Street, London WC2H 9JQ