Skip to main content
The Actuary: The magazine of the Institute and Faculty of Actuaries - return to the homepage Logo of The Actuary website
  • Search
  • Visit The Actuary Magazine on Facebook
  • Visit The Actuary Magazine on LinkedIn
  • Visit @TheActuaryMag on Twitter
Visit the website of the Institute and Faculty of Actuaries Logo of the Institute and Faculty of Actuaries

Main navigation

  • News
  • Features
    • General Features
    • Interviews
    • Students
    • Opinion
  • Topics
  • Knowledge
    • Business Skills
    • Careers
    • Events
    • Predictions by The Actuary
    • Whitepapers
    • Moody's - Climate Risk Insurers series
    • Webinars
    • Podcasts
  • Jobs
  • IFoA
    • CEO Comment
    • IFoA News
    • People & Social News
    • President Comment
  • Archive
Quick links:
  • Home
  • The Actuary Issues
  • July 2012
07

Hedging your bets

Open-access content Wednesday 25th July 2012 — updated 12.53pm, Wednesday 6th May 2020

Ross Evans, Angelina Lai, Eamonn Phelan and Derek McLean consider the options for minimising balance sheet volatility

Ross Evans, Angelina Lai, Eamonn Phelan and Derek McLean consider the options for minimising balance sheet volatility
Limiting risk on hedge funds - authors

On 21 March 2012, the European Parliament's Committee on Economic and Monetary Affairs (ECON) voted to agree its position on the Solvency II Omnibus II text.

A key aspect of the 'compromise package' - relating to the extrapolation of the risk-free
rate curve for Euro-denominated liabilities - will create signifi cant challenges for hedging.

The ECON proposal is as follows:

  • The starting point for the extrapolation of the curve shall be 20 years.
     
  • The extrapolated part of the curve will converge to an ultimate forward rate (UFR) of 4.2% by no more than 10 years after the entry point into the extrapolation.


For an insurer wishing to minimise balance sheet volatility, the proposals produce unstable and unintuitive hedges for liabilities beyond 20 years. One reason is that the extrapolation methodology itself creates an artificial exposure to the slope of the market swap curve preceding the entry point into the extrapolation.

Long-dated liabilities

There are different considerations to be borne in mind for liabilities falling due before and after the entry point into the extrapolation.

For liabilities that fall due before this point, the Solvency II hedge lines up closely with the equivalent market consistent hedge. This is because the risk-free rate curves are effectively the same under both frameworks.

For liabilities falling due after this point, however, the situation is quite different.

Figure 1 shows the delta hedge for a 50-year bullet liability of €10m valued under three different bases:

? Market consistent - market swap curve.
? Solvency II - 20-year entry point and 10 years to reach UFR.
? Solvency II - 20-year entry point and 40 years to reach UFR.

figure 1
Basis 2 represents the ECON proposal, while Basis 3 represents our understanding of the longer convergence period that is favoured by both the European Council and the European Commission.

There is a material change in the delta hedge when we move from a market consistent framework to Solvency II.

First, we see that the Solvency II hedges do not include any swaps beyond 20 years. This is because the long-dated liability is valued using an extrapolated curve that completely ignores market swap rates beyond this point.

Second, the Solvency II hedge comprises a long position in a 20-year swap and a short position in a 15-year swap. This is in stark contrast to the intuitive hedge under a market consistent framework, where the hedge is essentially a long position in a 50-year swap. The reason for this is that the 50-year point on the Solvency II discount curve is highly sensitive to the slope of the market swap curve preceding the entry point into the extrapolation, for instance, between 15 and 20 years. This sensitivity increases the longer it takes for the extrapolation to reach the UFR.

Third, the volume of swaps needed to hedge the long-dated liability reduces significantly under Solvency II, particularly when there is a short convergence period (such as 10 years). This is owing to an effective shortening of the modified duration of our long-dated liability.

Why is this? Solvency II uses market rates up to 20 years, converges over a short period to the UFR and then forward rates remain fixed at that level thereafter. So a 50-year liability looks and feels more akin to a 20- or 30-year liability in terms of interest rate sensitivity. This is demonstrated in Table 1, which shows how the 'PV01' (change in value of liability due to 1bp parallel shift to swap curve) and modified durations change when we move from a market consistent framework to Solvency II.

It is interesting to look at a back-test using historical data for the market swap curve between December 2009 and March 2012. Figure 2 shows how a Solvency II hedge would have varied over this period (assuming a 50-year bullet liability of €10m, a 10-year convergence period and monthly rebalancing).

Figure 2
Robustness of delta hedging

The Solvency II hedge (comprising a long position in a 20-year swap and a short position in a 15-year swap) is considerably more volatile over time than the market consistent hedge.

This would have required frequent, significant, rebalancing of market exposure (in addition to a gradual lengthening of the swap maturity as the outstanding liability term shortens). The market consistent hedge, however, would have required very little rebalancing.

The delta hedges we have looked at are designed to stabilise the balance sheet for small movements in interest rates. As demonstrated by our back-testing analysis, while this may give acceptable results in a market consistent framework, these hedges do not appear sufficiently robust under Solvency II.

Further, there is the added complication of managing the trade-off between capital stability and capital minimisation. The SCR standard formula requires the insurer to stress its balance sheet against much larger changes in interest rates, and it also makes an implicit allowance for a change in the level of the UFR via the tapering of the interest rate stresses at the long end of the curve.

Consequently, insurers will have to look beyond traditional delta hedging techniques when designing and implementing hedges to safeguard their Solvency II balance sheets. This may necessitate stress-testing thebalance sheet against more severe changes in interest rates and consideration of options based strategies.

Table 1

Balance sheet volatility

Lastly, it is important to bear in mind that there may be other drivers of balance sheet volatility, apart from the extrapolation of the Solvency II risk-free rate curve.

Consider an insurer that invests solely in government bonds, while valuing its liabilities in accordance with the Solvency II risk-free rate curve. Prior to the financial crisis, this may have been seen as an appropriate hedging strategy, as government bond yields and swap rates tended to move in step with one another, immunising the balance sheet against interest rates changes.

Post-crisis, however, government bond yields have widened relative to swap rates, introducing fresh volatility to balance sheets. Issues such as this have an important bearing on the effectiveness of any hedging scheme.

An insurer should not be indifferent when choosing swaps or government bonds as its preferred tool for duration management. To effectively hedge the balance sheet, it may be necessary to reduce its holding of government bonds in favour of interest rate swaps, or alternatively, to hedge the basis risk between its government bond portfolio and liabilities valued using swaps.

Ross Evans, Angelina Lai, Eamonn Phelan and Derek McLean report on behalf of the 'How to hedge the risk-free rate under Solvency II' working party. The group's other members are Paul Collins, Oliver Firth, David Johnson, Emily Penn and Alex Probyn
This article appeared in our July 2012 issue of The Actuary .
Click here to view this issue

You may also be interested in...

ta filler

Modelling the 1-in-200 Risks

Tail risks of life catastrophe arise from extreme events, such as pandemics or terrorist attacks. Because such events are rare, recent mortality experience data doesn't help with estimating the risk from future extreme events.
Monday 20th August 2012
Open-access content
ta

Q&A Cass Business School scholarship case study

Nikhil shares his experiences as a scholarship recipient at Cass Business School, his views on life as an actuary in India, and the vision for alumni to support students when they can
Friday 27th July 2012
Open-access content

Changing lives through facilitating scholarships

Dr Ben Rickayzen reports on the Haberman Campaign, which raises funding for actuarial scholarships at the Cass Business School in London
Monday 30th July 2012
Open-access content
ta

Disability Income: Are we sitting on a time-bomb?

Andy Rear considers lessons learned from the Australian Disability Income Insurance market and warns against complacency in the UK IP market
Monday 30th July 2012
Open-access content

Afterthought to artform

In the second of his two-part series on soft skills, Simon Carne explains the background to the Profession’s masterclass in the art of communication
Tuesday 31st July 2012
Open-access content

History in the making

Dr Ruth Levitt offers a glimpse into the origins of life insurance in Victorian Britain, following the life and death of one of the early policyholders, Frederick Kensett, through the Equitable’s archives
Tuesday 31st July 2012
Open-access content

Latest from Risk & ERM

KV

Liability-driven investments: new landscape

What now for liability-driven investments, after last year’s crash in the market? Pensions experts Rakesh Girdharlal and Moiz Khan say it should lead to a more balanced approach
Wednesday 1st February 2023
Open-access content
cj

Natural capital investing

Chris Howells and Andrew Dreaneen discuss how today’s investments in natural capital profit portfolios as well as the planet and humanity
Wednesday 1st February 2023
Open-access content
bl

'Takaful' models of Islamic insurance

Ethical, varied and a growing market – ‘takaful’ Islamic insurance is worth knowing about, wherever you’re from and whatever your beliefs, says Ali Asghar Bhuriwala
Wednesday 1st February 2023
Open-access content

Latest from July 2012

2

CEO's comment: Racing start for public affairs

Derek Cribb explains how reinvigorating research offers the key to thought leadership
Wednesday 3rd October 2012
Open-access content
2

CEO's comment: Going for a global gold

Derek Cribb explains why education is key to a universally successful future for the Profession
Friday 3rd August 2012
Open-access content
2

President's comment: A blooming vision

Having watched the seeds being planted, Philip Scott now wants to see the actuarial profession blossom and grow
Thursday 2nd August 2012
Open-access content

Latest from formbuilder_item_removed

2

Implementing IFRS 17 Discount Curves: Theoretical and Practical Challenges

The International Financial Reporting Standard (IFRS) 17 requires liability cash flows to be discounted at rates that reflect the characteristics of the cash flows, including their liquidity
Tuesday 3rd September 2019
Open-access content
2

Profit Emergence Under IFRS 9 and IFRS 17: The impact of choice of liability discount rate

With the IFRS 17 accounting standard, insurers need to understand the patterns of profit emergence that arise under the standard, and how current business and methodology decisions affect such patterns.
Wednesday 10th July 2019
Open-access content
2

Whitepaper: Aggregation and diversification of the IFRS 17 Risk Adjustment

This paper forms part of a series of high-level papers designed to provide an introduction to different features of the risk adjustment that should be considered in advance of implementation.
Tuesday 29th January 2019
Open-access content

Latest from no_opening_image

TPR publishes coronavirus guidance

The Pensions Regulator (TPR) has published guidance to help UK pension trustees, employers and administrators deal with the financial and regulatory risks posed by coronavirus.
Monday 23rd March 2020
Open-access content
web_p24_cat-and-fish_iStock-483454069.png

Sensitivity analysis: swimming lessons

Silvana Pesenti, Alberto Bettini, Pietro Millossovich and Andreas Tsanakas present their alternative approach to sensitivity analysis
Wednesday 4th March 2020
Open-access content
ta

IFoA adjudication panel: Mr Jack Wicks, student

On 30 October 2019 the Adjudication Panel considered an allegation of misconduct against Mr Jack Wicks (the respondent).
Friday 28th February 2020
Open-access content

Latest from inline_image_missing_alt_text

TPR publishes coronavirus guidance

The Pensions Regulator (TPR) has published guidance to help UK pension trustees, employers and administrators deal with the financial and regulatory risks posed by coronavirus.
Monday 23rd March 2020
Open-access content
2

Bitcoin: In the vaults

Blockchain technology and the trading of bitcoin were introduced in October 2008 in the famous paper by Satoshi Nakamoto.
Wednesday 4th March 2020
Open-access content
web_p24_cat-and-fish_iStock-483454069.png

Sensitivity analysis: swimming lessons

Silvana Pesenti, Alberto Bettini, Pietro Millossovich and Andreas Tsanakas present their alternative approach to sensitivity analysis
Wednesday 4th March 2020
Open-access content

Latest from inline_image_undersized

2

Bitcoin: In the vaults

Blockchain technology and the trading of bitcoin were introduced in October 2008 in the famous paper by Satoshi Nakamoto.
Wednesday 4th March 2020
Open-access content
2

New frontiers of technology

Alizabeth Calder examines the challenges facing actuaries in an increasingly tech and data-based world
Thursday 3rd October 2019
Open-access content
2

The workforce of tomorrow

A group of employment professionals specialising in insurance and finance discuss emerging recruitment trends. Chris Seekings reports
Tuesday 6th August 2019
Open-access content

Latest from missing_standfirst

news in brief

March news in brief

Paper: A Cashless Society in 2019 Cash is under pressure. A tense 2018 led to a tumultuous 2019: Facebook's announcement of plans to launch its Libra cryptocurrency with a consortium of companies united all regulators against the project.
Friday 28th February 2020
Open-access content
2

Forging new paths

The Terminator is coming!  At least that's one potential vision of the future, invoked by Boris Johnson at the UN last year while he speculated about artificial intelligence (AI). We can certainly debate how realistic that vision is, and what the possible timescales might be.
Friday 28th February 2020
Open-access content
2

Expert advice

This edition of the magazine focuses on data science and its applications, which will be a recurring theme for the IFoA.
Friday 28th February 2020
Open-access content

Latest from 07

David Belsham

On my agenda: David Belsham

Jemima Ayton and Dan Georgescu talk to Prudential UK's chief actuary about his role and his belief in actuaries developing strong communication skills to broaden their careers
Tuesday 31st July 2012
Open-access content
2

Q&A Germany: Peter Devlin

Peter Devlin moved to Germany 10 years ago to continue his actuarial career. He now works as head of total rewards and human capital, M&A, at Deloitte. Here he recounts his experiences of life and work in the city of Munich
Friday 6th July 2012
Open-access content
2

An Indian summer for actuaries

Jagbir Sodhi highlights the rapid growth of the Indian economy, in particular the insurance sector, and explains why the country reveres the actuarial profession to almost celebrity status
Friday 6th July 2012
Open-access content
Share
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Linked in
  • Mail
  • Print

Latest Jobs

Shape the Future of Insurance

London (Central)
£ excellent package
Reference
149090

Senior Pricing Actuary - Life Reinsurance

London (Central)
£ excellent
Reference
149089

Insurance Investment Leadership Opportunities

Flexible / hybrid with 2 days p/w office-based
£ dependent upon experience
Reference
149088
See all jobs »
 
 
 
 

Sign up to our newsletter

News, jobs and updates

Sign up

Subscribe to The Actuary

Receive the print edition straight to your door

Subscribe
Spread-iPad-slantB-june.png

Topics

  • Data Science
  • Investment
  • Risk & ERM
  • Pensions
  • Environment
  • Soft skills
  • General Insurance
  • Regulation Standards
  • Health care
  • Technology
  • Reinsurance
  • Global
  • Life insurance
​
FOLLOW US
The Actuary on LinkedIn
@TheActuaryMag on Twitter
Facebook: The Actuary Magazine
CONTACT US
The Actuary
Tel: (+44) 020 7880 6200
​

IFoA

About IFoA
Become an actuary
IFoA Events
About membership

Information

Privacy Policy
Terms & Conditions
Cookie Policy
Think Green

Get in touch

Contact us
Advertise with us
Subscribe to The Actuary Magazine
Contribute

The Actuary Jobs

Actuarial job search
Pensions jobs
General insurance jobs
Solvency II jobs

© 2023 The Actuary. The Actuary is published on behalf of the Institute and Faculty of Actuaries by Redactive Publishing Limited. All rights reserved. Reproduction of any part is not allowed without written permission.

Redactive Media Group Ltd, 71-75 Shelton Street, London WC2H 9JQ