Skip to main content
The Actuary: The magazine of the Institute and Faculty of Actuaries - return to the homepage Logo of The Actuary website
  • Search
  • Visit The Actuary Magazine on Facebook
  • Visit The Actuary Magazine on LinkedIn
  • Visit @TheActuaryMag on Twitter
Visit the website of the Institute and Faculty of Actuaries Logo of the Institute and Faculty of Actuaries

Main navigation

  • News
  • Features
    • General Features
    • Interviews
    • Students
    • Opinion
  • Topics
  • Knowledge
    • Business Skills
    • Careers
    • Events
    • Predictions by The Actuary
    • Whitepapers
    • Moody's - Climate Risk Insurers series
    • Webinars
    • Podcasts
  • Jobs
  • IFoA
    • CEO Comment
    • IFoA News
    • People & Social News
    • President Comment
  • Archive
Quick links:
  • Home
  • The Actuary Issues
  • August 2017
08

A nation divided?

Open-access content Monday 7th August 2017 — updated 5.50pm, Wednesday 29th April 2020

Are there really differences in life expectancy between Scotland and the rest of the UK? If so, how should actuaries take account of these? Phil Caine and Susan Hanlon discuss

2


Do people in Scotland live shorter lives than the rest of the UK? If they do, on average, isn't this easily explained by different balances of socio-economic groups and areas of particularly high deprivation? After all, it's not as if we expect Scottish actuaries, lawyers or doctors to have lower life expectancy than their counterparts elsewhere. Is Scotland really that different from the north of England and what about the other parts of the UK?

National statistics (figure 1) show a consistent, clear gap between the period life expectancies at 65 in Scotland and England for both men and women at a population level. Research from National Records for Scotland shows that men in England, Wales and Northern Ireland can expect to live longer than those in Scotland by 2.3, 1.3 and 1.2 years respectively.

Figure 1

But national statistics can only take you so far. So, we investigated how far the Mercer Mortality Model, which uses a pooled dataset from over 1 million public and private sector DB pension beneficiaries, can explain the differences seen in Scotland.

After validation and removal of duplicates, the dataset includes more than four million life-years of experience - 95% of the records have a valid UK postcode and there is good geographical coverage across the whole of the UK. Using academically-reviewed methods, a Makeham-Perks force of mortality model was fitted to actual death data using Longevitas survival-modelling software.

The model differentiates mortality rates by age and gender, and splits out retirees before age 50 to capture ill-health effects. Using the Akaike Information Criterion, we then established six pension size bands and seven lifestyle groupings (from postcode 'types' provided by a commercial profiler). Every individual postcode is separately categorised using the full six to eight-character code, allowing more granularity and avoiding traditional problems with using broader areas that might contain a varied mix of housing types.  

The spread of outcomes is very powerful - one male pensioner can be shown to be over four times more likely to die at age 65 than another, and another to have over seven years' higher life expectancy at 65, based on lifestyle and pension size alone. On average, we see lower pension sizes and less affluent lifestyle groups in Scotland, but that doesn't quite tell the full story.

We then tested adding 'geographical' risk factors to our model. They showed a gap between Scottish experience and the expectations already in the model - small, but nonetheless material as far as pension scheme funding goes. Thanks to the size of our dataset, we can consider these differences to be statistically significant. We also saw a similar but smaller effect heading south through England, with those in the South of England living slightly longer than the model suggested - enough to reasonably allow for another dividing line. Using optimisation techniques, we found that the line of latitude which gave the best fit for the 'North-South divide' starts on the west coast in the Mersey estuary, runs south of Liverpool and Manchester, straight through Sheffield and ends on the east coast in Lincolnshire, south of the Humber.

The resulting difference in like-for-like life expectancy between Scotland and the south of England is about nine months, with the other regions of the UK lying in between. Testing all seven lifestyle groups consistently showed lower life expectancies for the Scottish individuals in those groups (figure 2). This supports the hypothesis that there is a geographical component to life expectancy that can't be completely explained by income and housing/lifestyle factors.

Given this difference, is there further evidence to support it? We reviewed recent medical research which revealed evidence for a number of theories which could provide some explanation.

DIET - Research published in the British Medical Journal has shown that, although the English diet is far from perfect, the Scottish diet tends to be worse, and that if the Scots were to adopt the 'English diet' - eating more fruit and vegetables, and consuming less salt and saturated fat - the mortality gap between Scotland and England in terms of coronary heart disease, stroke and cancer could be reduced by around 40%.

ALCOHOL and SMOKING - Studies have shown that, across most socio-economic groups, and both sexes, there is more high-risk drinking, alcohol-related deaths, and smoking in Scotland and northern England compared to the rest of the UK. 

DE-INDUSTRIALISATION - An interesting study of post-industrial areas across northern Europe showed former coal mining and industrial areas had higher rates of mortality, even after adjusting for migration and individual characteristics. This chimes with our north-south divide, with the line separating areas of previously heavy industry to the north and more affluent areas to the south. Although this effect was seen in all of the areas studied, it was worst in Scotland. 

WEATHER - 'Too much rain, not enough sunshine' is a popular theory for the Scotland effect, but excess mortality appears to be far more associated with white people in Scotland than ethnic minority groups who have higher levels of vitamin D deficiency.

Figure 2


In reality, the Scotland effect seems likely to be due to a complex combination of factors like these.

The other bad news from the de-industrialisation study was that these types of regional inequalities in mortality tended to persist over time (see figure 1). Even as life expectancies in both Scotland and the rest of the UK have increased, the gaps between the two have persisted and even widened over the years.

If the Scots' diet and smoking rates do improve, they're likely to still remain behind England for some time as England improves too. Early life can cast long shadows and many of the issues relating to de-industrialisation, for example, could continue to have a large impact on the life expectancies in the affected populations for a long time to come. So what do we, as actuaries, do with this data?

Don't get overly distracted by national or regional differences. Inequalities in life expectancy will generally increase for smaller areas as we divide the population into smaller, increasingly homogenous groups. Regional state pension ages, for example, wouldn't address the inequalities that are often seen from one street to the next.

Do ensure you consider all material rating factors available to you. The geographical layer was added to our model as a further refinement after we had already explained much of the difference in life expectancies by more commonly-used factors such as income, socio-economic/housing-based lifestyle groups, and retirement age. Those commonly used-factors remain the most powerful predictors, and should be considered in any model. 

Don't completely ignore the additional differences though. Consider what the additional impact could be. In the current low interest rate environment, allowance for a Scottish-based membership could impact the liabilities of a DB pension by 3% or more. 


Phil Caine is an actuary who leads Mercer's longevity analysis for DB pension schemes

Susan Hanlon is an actuary in Mercer's Policy, Professionalism and Research team


This article appeared in our August 2017 issue of The Actuary .
Click here to view this issue

You may also be interested in...

2

Is de-risking in members' best interests?

Traditional asset-liability modelling for defined benefit pension schemes ignores covenant risk. Integrating this risk may suggest that a higher allocation to return-seeking assets makes sense, say Robert Waugh, Nic Barnes and Robert Chestnutt
Monday 7th August 2017
Open-access content
2

Mortality improvements in decline

Jon Palin, on behalf of the CMI Mortality Projections Committee, reviews the growing evidence for a slowing down of mortality improvements in the UK, noting the trend for pension scheme members is less clear
Monday 7th August 2017
Open-access content
2

Changing world health

Dr John Schoonbee talks to Gemma Gregson and Richard Purcell about reinventing dietary guidelines, e-cigarettes and advances in diagnostic techniques
Monday 7th August 2017
Open-access content
2

Perfecting proxy models

Shaun Lazzari and Oliver Bentley look at managing sources of inaccuracy in Least Squares Monte Carlo proxy model fitting
Tuesday 8th August 2017
Open-access content
2

Book review: Insurance in Elizabethan England

Insurance in Elizabethan England – The London Code Cambridge Studies in English Legal History
Tuesday 8th August 2017
Open-access content
2

Are you a pusher or a puller?

Ally Yates explains how to use the right strategy for the right situation when negotiating and influencing
Tuesday 8th August 2017
Open-access content

Latest from August 2017

2

Government announces tough new measures to tackle pension cold calling

The UK government announced yesterday that it would ban cold calls and tighten protections against transfers to fraudulent schemes.
Friday 18th August 2017
Open-access content
2

British Steel Pension Scheme to separate from Tata Steel

The Pensions Regulator has today approved a proposal from Tata Steel UK (TSUK) to separate itself from the British Steel Pension Scheme (BSPS), to avoid the company becoming insolvent.
Friday 11th August 2017
Open-access content

Erratic expectations

I was interested to learn from Alex Waite’s July article (bit.ly/AnimalSpiritsAW) there is an Economic Modelling Group aiming at improving forecasting of economic outcomes. I wish this the best of luck, but would not be surprised if the results prove inconclusive. Honorary fellows are eminent individuals in business, academia and government.
Tuesday 8th August 2017
Open-access content

Latest from small_opening_image

2

COVID-19 forum for actuaries launched

A forum for actuaries has been launched to help the profession come together and learn how best to respond to the deadly coronavirus sweeping the world.
Wednesday 25th March 2020
Open-access content
2

Travel insurers expect record payouts this year

UK travel insurers expect to pay a record £275m to customers this year as coronavirus grounds flights across the world, the Association of British Insurers (ABI) has revealed.
Wednesday 25th March 2020
Open-access content
2

Grim economic forecasts made as countries lockdown

A sharp recession is imminent in the vast majority of developed and emerging economies as the deadly coronavirus forces businesses to shut down across the world.
Tuesday 24th March 2020
Open-access content

Latest from 08

2

Fail to prepare

Fail to prepare
Tuesday 8th August 2017
Open-access content

Paying LPI service to market prices

Robin Thompson and Andrew Kenyon look at how liabilities linked to Limited Price Indexation can create risk
Monday 7th August 2017
Open-access content
Share
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Linked in
  • Mail
  • Print

Latest Jobs

Senior Manager - Building new team!

London (Central)
Up to £130k + Bonus
Reference
148845

Shape the Future of Credit Risk Model Development

Flexible / hybrid with 2 days p/w office-based
£ six figure salary with excellent bonus potential + package
Reference
148843

Longevity Director

Flexible / hybrid with 2 days p/w office-based
£ six figure salary with excellent bonus potential + package
Reference
148842
See all jobs »
 
 
 
 

Sign up to our newsletter

News, jobs and updates

Sign up

Subscribe to The Actuary

Receive the print edition straight to your door

Subscribe
Spread-iPad-slantB-june.png

Topics

  • Data Science
  • Investment
  • Risk & ERM
  • Pensions
  • Environment
  • Soft skills
  • General Insurance
  • Regulation Standards
  • Health care
  • Technology
  • Reinsurance
  • Global
  • Life insurance
​
FOLLOW US
The Actuary on LinkedIn
@TheActuaryMag on Twitter
Facebook: The Actuary Magazine
CONTACT US
The Actuary
Tel: (+44) 020 7880 6200
​

IFoA

About IFoA
Become an actuary
IFoA Events
About membership

Information

Privacy Policy
Terms & Conditions
Cookie Policy
Think Green

Get in touch

Contact us
Advertise with us
Subscribe to The Actuary Magazine
Contribute

The Actuary Jobs

Actuarial job search
Pensions jobs
General insurance jobs
Solvency II jobs

© 2023 The Actuary. The Actuary is published on behalf of the Institute and Faculty of Actuaries by Redactive Publishing Limited. All rights reserved. Reproduction of any part is not allowed without written permission.

Redactive Media Group Ltd, 71-75 Shelton Street, London WC2H 9JQ