Skip to main content
The Actuary: The magazine of the Institute and Faculty of Actuaries - return to the homepage Logo of The Actuary website
  • Search
  • Visit The Actuary Magazine on Facebook
  • Visit The Actuary Magazine on LinkedIn
  • Visit @TheActuaryMag on Twitter
Visit the website of the Institute and Faculty of Actuaries Logo of the Institute and Faculty of Actuaries

Main navigation

  • News
  • Features
    • General Features
    • Interviews
    • Students
    • Opinion
  • Topics
  • Knowledge
    • Business Skills
    • Careers
    • Events
    • Predictions by The Actuary
    • Whitepapers
    • Moody's - Climate Risk Insurers series
    • Webinars
    • Podcasts
  • Jobs
  • IFoA
    • CEO Comment
    • IFoA News
    • People & Social News
    • President Comment
  • Archive
Quick links:
  • Home
  • The Actuary Issues
  • December 2020
General Features

Tuesday's child

Open-access content Wednesday 2nd December 2020 — updated 10.45am, Tuesday 4th May 2021
Authors
Kevin Olding

Kevin Olding peels apart a perplexing puzzle in probability

web_p38-39_iStock-1277020057.jpg

The so-called ‘Tuesday boy’ probability puzzle gives insight into both conditional probability and 
the nature of mathematical modelling around uncertainty. It is a problem that is able to shock, frustrate and delight – and can lead to continued disagreement even among those who clearly understand its athematical solution. As such, it is an essential education for anyone in the business of explaining risk modelling to general audiences.

1. A simpler version of the puzzle has long been a feature of introductory probability classes: 

Two boys: You meet a new colleague who tells you “I have two children, one of whom is a boy.”  What is the probability that both your colleague’s children are boys?

Many respond that the answer is ‘obviously’ ½, only for the puzzle setter to reveal the ‘true’ answer of ⅓, along with the following reasoning. Suppose each child is either a boy (B) or girl (G) with equal probability, and the genders of the two children are independent. There are then four possibilities for pairs of children {BB, BG, GB, GG}, each occurring with equal probability. Conditional on one of these children being a boy, three equally likely outcomes remain {BB, BG, GB}, and so the probability that both children are boys is  ⅓.

The logic is irrefutable, but somehow unconvincing for many, and indeed there is a much less discussed hidden layer to this problem that several variants help to reveal. 
 

2. The ‘Tuesday boy’ variant of the problem, first showed to me by a colleague while I was teaching at Dulwich College in London, left me in an initial state of disbelief:

Tuesday boy: You meet a new colleague who tells you “I have two children, one of whom is a boy who was born on a Tuesday.” What is the probability that both your colleague’s children are boys?

How can knowing the boy was born on a Tuesday have any bearing on this problem? Surely this is independent of, and irrelevant to, the original problem? However, careful analysis shows us that the additional information does indeed change the correct answer to a value much closer to ½. 

To see why, subdivide each of the four cases {BB, BG, GB, GG} into 49 possibilities of pairs of days on which each child could have been born. There are now 196 possibilities in total, each equally likely. There are 27 combinations that include a boy born on a Tuesday; of these, 13 have two boys, both born on Tuesday. Therefore, the probability of two boys is now 13/27 – quite close to ½ (Figure 1).

Figure 1

3. Consider a further seasonal variant for emphasis:

Christmas boy: You meet a new colleague who tells you “I have two children, one of whom is a boy who was born on Christmas Day.” What is the probability that both your colleague’s children are boys?

If we assume 365 days in the year, with births independent and equally likely on each day, then a similar argument yields an answer of 729/1,459 – even closer to ½. 
 

4. Again, these mathematically irrefutable answers leave us searching for intuition, and a final variant is helpful to understand what is going on:

This boy: You meet a new colleague; he is sitting with a boy, who he introduces as one of his two children. What is the probability that both your colleague’s children are boys?

This is the simplest case of all, and the answer is ½ – though if you have thought too much about the previous puzzles, you would be forgiven for any doubt! In this variant, there is a particular child in front of you. A second child is somewhere else, and is equally likely to be a boy or a girl. Similarly, if you know the eldest child is a boy, the probability that the other is a boy is also ½. Writing the births in order, there are two of the four cases remaining {BG, BB} and the probability of two boys is clearly ½.
 

Applied probability

In each of these four problems, the answer depends on how specifically the information you are given identifies a particular child. If it is unlikely you would have two children satisfying the condition – for example being born on Christmas Day – then the answer is very close to ½. In the case of the particular child being in front of you, it is impossible that both children are that child, so the answer is ½. If the information is more generic, the probability will be closer to ⅓.

Even with this intuition, we may be left questioning whether this problem really makes sense as an applied probability question. In the initial ‘two boys’ problem, why do we accept the inference that the probabilities of each of the four outcomes are equally likely, and that the information you are given is conditioning these to {BB, BG, GB}? If someone said in conversation “I have two children, one of whom is a boy”, common experience tells us that, a very high proportion of the time, the speaker would have one boy and one girl, unless they are a probability puzzle setter. 

There is something special about how the ‘Tuesday boy’ problem provokes debate. As well as being an interesting conditional probability puzzle, it helps us reflect on the nature of applied probability. The correct meaning of probability in this context, and perhaps in all applied probability problems, is that it represents uncertainty about the information we hold, rather than some inherent randomness of nature. As such, valid solutions to these problems are as much about the initial modelling assumptions as the technicalities of the pure probability. This makes them a particularly useful part of any education about modelling uncertainty in a professional context. 

5. I leave you with a variant of my own creation – please tweet your answers to @mathsaurus and @TheActuaryMag.

Actuary boy: Your colleague passes you the latest edition of The Actuary magazine containing an article stating that 35% of actuaries are female and tells you “I have two children, one of whom is an actuary.” What is the probability that both your colleague’s children are boys?


Kevin Olding is the creator of the Mathsaurus website (mathsaurus.com) and YouTube channel, and a PhD student in the SAMBa Doctoral Training Centre at the University of Bath

Image Credit: iStock
ACT Dec20_Full.jpg
This article appeared in our December 2020 issue of The Actuary .
Click here to view this issue

You may also be interested in...

web_p22-25_081218-03 [Converted].jpg

A new domain

A new domain
Wednesday 2nd December 2020
Open-access content
web_p32-33_shutterstock_169721648 [Converted].jpg

Who do we think you are?

Who do we think you are?
Wednesday 2nd December 2020
Open-access content
After the dust settles

After the dust settles

After the dust settles
Wednesday 2nd December 2020
Open-access content
web_p40_iStock-1215953761 [Converted].jpg

From FIA to IFA

From FIA to IFA What is an independent financial advisor, how do you become one, and why is this relevant to actuaries? Darryl Boulton explains
Wednesday 2nd December 2020
Open-access content
web_p35_iStock-1146518933.jpg

Guiding lights

Bradley Shearer is executive director of Protagion Active Career Management, actuary and CFA charterholder
Wednesday 2nd December 2020
Open-access content
Celebrating 30 years

A trip through time

The Actuary has been connecting the actuarial community since 1990. In this 30th anniversary commemorative edition, some of our past editors tell us about their time at the helm
Wednesday 2nd December 2020
Open-access content

Latest from Modelling/software

EG\

Uneven outcomes: findings on cancer mortality

Ayşe Arık, Andrew Cairns, Erengul Dodd, Adam Shao and George Streftaris share their findings on the impact of socio-economic differences and diagnostic delays on cancer mortality
Wednesday 1st June 2022
Open-access content
dtj

Talking census: making use of data

With the ONS starting to release the data from the 2021 census, Jeremy Keating considers how those working in insurance can make use of it
Wednesday 1st June 2022
Open-access content
hrts

Storm watch: Can IPCC models be used in cat modelling?

Can IPCC projections be used to adjust catastrophe models for climate change? Nigel Winspear and David Maneval investigate, using US hurricanes as an example
Wednesday 1st June 2022
Open-access content

Latest from General Insurance

td

Brain power

The latest microchips mimic cerebral function. Smaller, faster and more efficient than their predecessors, they have the potential to save lives and help insurers, argues Amarnath Suggu
Wednesday 1st March 2023
Open-access content
bl

'Takaful' models of Islamic insurance

Ethical, varied and a growing market – ‘takaful’ Islamic insurance is worth knowing about, wherever you’re from and whatever your beliefs, says Ali Asghar Bhuriwala
Wednesday 1st February 2023
Open-access content
il

When 'human' isn't female

It was only last year that the first anatomically correct female crash test dummy was created. With so much data still based on the male perspective, are we truly meeting all consumer needs? Adél Drew discusses her thoughts, based on the book Invisible Women by Caroline Criado Perez
Wednesday 1st February 2023
Open-access content

Latest from General Features

yguk

Is anybody out there?

There’s no point speaking if no one hears you. Effective communication starts with silence – this is the understated art of listening, says Tan Suee Chieh
Thursday 2nd March 2023
Open-access content
ers

By halves

Reducing the pensions gap between men and women is a work in progress – and there’s still a long way to go, with women retiring on 50% less than men, says Alexandra Miles
Thursday 2nd March 2023
Open-access content
web_Question-mark-lightbulbs_credit_iStock-1348235111.png

Figuring it out

Psychologist Wendy Johnson recalls how qualifying as an actuary and running her own consultancy in the US allowed her to overcome shyness and gave her essential skills for life
Wednesday 1st March 2023
Open-access content

Latest from Kevin Olding

Sketch

Interview with Andreas Kyprianou: Era of Mathematics

Andreas Kyprianou tells Kevin Olding and Dan Georgescu how maths is helping humanity face down some of its biggest challenges – from COVID-19 to global air pollution
Wednesday 7th April 2021
Open-access content

Latest from December 2020

Fiasco

Fiasco: An amateur joy

As The Actuary celebrates its 30th birthday, David Raymont digs into the archives to acknowledge its predecessor Fiasco, which ran for 127 issues between February 1978 and June 1990
Wednesday 2nd December 2020
Open-access content
web_p43_IFoA Foundation Logo - gold & blue - CMYK.jpg

People and society news: December

People and society news: December
Wednesday 2nd December 2020
Open-access content
web_p41_student_scarsbrook_dec.jpg

Student: Widening the net

Arpit Surana is a guest student editor
Wednesday 2nd December 2020
Open-access content
Share
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Linked in
  • Mail
  • Print

Latest Jobs

Senior Manager - Building new team!

London (Central)
Up to £130k + Bonus
Reference
148845

Shape the Future of Credit Risk Model Development

Flexible / hybrid with 2 days p/w office-based
£ six figure salary with excellent bonus potential + package
Reference
148843

Longevity Director

Flexible / hybrid with 2 days p/w office-based
£ six figure salary with excellent bonus potential + package
Reference
148842
See all jobs »
 
 
 
 

Sign up to our newsletter

News, jobs and updates

Sign up

Subscribe to The Actuary

Receive the print edition straight to your door

Subscribe
Spread-iPad-slantB-june.png

Topics

  • Data Science
  • Investment
  • Risk & ERM
  • Pensions
  • Environment
  • Soft skills
  • General Insurance
  • Regulation Standards
  • Health care
  • Technology
  • Reinsurance
  • Global
  • Life insurance
​
FOLLOW US
The Actuary on LinkedIn
@TheActuaryMag on Twitter
Facebook: The Actuary Magazine
CONTACT US
The Actuary
Tel: (+44) 020 7880 6200
​

IFoA

About IFoA
Become an actuary
IFoA Events
About membership

Information

Privacy Policy
Terms & Conditions
Cookie Policy
Think Green

Get in touch

Contact us
Advertise with us
Subscribe to The Actuary Magazine
Contribute

The Actuary Jobs

Actuarial job search
Pensions jobs
General insurance jobs
Solvency II jobs

© 2023 The Actuary. The Actuary is published on behalf of the Institute and Faculty of Actuaries by Redactive Publishing Limited. All rights reserved. Reproduction of any part is not allowed without written permission.

Redactive Media Group Ltd, 71-75 Shelton Street, London WC2H 9JQ