[Skip to content]

Sign up for our daily newsletter
The Actuary The magazine of the Institute & Faculty of Actuaries

Hymans Robertson monitoring supports de-risking decisions

Hymans Robertson has launched a quarterly buy-in monitoring service which aims to help pension funds to make ‘informed decisions’ if and when they pay to de-risk their schemes.


The service reflects the actuarial company’s belief that tracking the price of various forms of pension scheme risk transfer options is vital to ensuring trustees, pension managers and finance directors understand when it is the right time to do a deal and which type of deal best meets their objectives.

James Mullins, partner and head of buy-out solutions at Hymans Robertson, said: ‘A buy-in represents an excellent hedge to the risks faced by a pension scheme and is sometimes overlooked as an alternative to gilts or a liability-driven investment strategy. Different insurers price buy-in differently and relative pricing fluctuates over time.’

According to Hymans Robertson, schemes considering using gilts to fund a pensioner buy-in exercise could currently see ‘significantly’ more value in their transaction than would have been the case a year ago. Buy-ins are particularly well priced at present for mature schemes with lots of older pensioner members, it added.

Mr Mullins explained that poor performance from equities over the course of 2011 had moved schemes further away from buy-out plans. Equity rallies in the last three months of the year were only able to keep track of the increase in buy-out premiums caused by failing yields.

In contrast, current dynamics in buy-in prices offer an ‘interesting opportunity’ to increase efficiency in hedging strategies, he said. ‘Schemes should investigate them,’ he added.

Generally schemes hold government gilts, or other ‘matching assets’, to broadly match some of the pension payments they expect to pay out. These assets would typically be used to meet the cost of buy-in.

‘The good news for pension schemes is that, whilst the cost of a buy-in will have increased in absolute terms as a result of the fall in long-term interest rates, the cost of a buy-in relative to the value of these matching assets is likely to have fallen quite significantly,’ Mr Mullins said.

‘Indeed, current market conditions and pricing mean that the cost of a buy-in that insures older pensioner payments will often be cheaper than the value of government gilts or a liability-driven investment  strategy to broadly match the same pension payments.’

A scheme could, he said, sell £100m of gilts providing only a reasonable match for pensioner payments and at the same time buy a buy-in policy for £98m that provides an excellent match for the same pensioner payments.

This would reduce risk and improve the pension scheme’s balance sheet position at the same time, Mr Mullin explained, providing ‘a great result for trustees, sponsoring employers and, most importantly, pension scheme members’.

Please enter your comments below
Fill out the all the boxes and click the 'Submit comments' button to make a comment on this page
*Comments are added to the bottom of the page. They are moderated and will not be published until approved by The Actuary team. They may be edited.